Short answer: They almost never match on their own. ServiceTitan costs labor with a burden rate someone typed in. Your payroll provider pays the real wages. That journal usually lands in QuickBooks Online. Payroll doesn’t export from ServiceTitan. Load an honest burden rate, fix timesheets before payroll is approved, and compare the two totals every month.

By Rex Biggs II, CPA, founder of Rektio Accounting. Rektio is a bookkeeping and controller team in Fishers, Indiana. We keep the books in QuickBooks Online for HVAC, plumbing and electrical companies on ServiceTitan across the US.

Why do my jobs look profitable when the P&L says otherwise?

Short answer: Because the job report only knows the labor cost you told it about. If the burden rate is missing or stale, every job looks better than it was.

Here’s the call I get. “ServiceTitan says our jobs run 45% gross margin. The P&L says we barely made money. Which one is lying?”

Usually neither. They’re answering different questions with different data.

  • ServiceTitan knows the job: the invoice, the tech’s hours on that job, the parts on the PO. Its labor number is hours times whatever rate is loaded on the technician.
  • Your payroll provider knows what you actually paid: gross wages, overtime, employer taxes, workers’ comp, benefits, PTO and holidays. That usually posts to QuickBooks Online as a journal entry, which knows the dollars but almost nothing about which job they went to.

When those two numbers are miles apart, the gap is almost always labor, and the biggest piece of that gap is the burden rate.

I’ve walked into shops where no burden rate was loaded at all. The hours were there, but taxes, PTO, holidays, benefits and workers’ comp never touched a single job. The owner was pricing work off margins that didn’t exist.

Where does payroll actually go after ServiceTitan?

Short answer: To your payroll provider. The provider’s payroll journal is what usually lands in QuickBooks Online.

ServiceTitan’s help docs say payroll doesn’t export directly to QuickBooks. The flow looks like this:

  1. Techs clock time in ServiceTitan.
  2. A manager approves the pay period.
  3. You send the approved hours to your payroll provider, often as a Master Pay File.
  4. The provider pays people. A payroll journal, from the provider or entered by hand, lands in QuickBooks Online.

Some providers, like Inova (UKG Ready), connect directly to ServiceTitan, which helps, but you still need the burden rate set right. Other shops use ADP, Paychex, Gusto, QuickBooks Payroll, Paylocity or another provider. Either way, ServiceTitan holds the hours and an estimated cost per job, and QuickBooks Online holds the actual dollars. If anyone edits hours only in the payroll system, the two drift apart and nobody notices until month-end.

What is a burden rate, and what goes in it?

Short answer: It’s the extra cost per hour of having a tech on the payroll, on top of their wage. Get it close, not perfect, and don’t count anything twice.

A tech who makes $30 an hour costs you more than $30. The burden covers the rest. Most shops build it from:

  • Employer payroll taxes
  • Workers’ comp
  • Health insurance and other benefits
  • Paid time off and holidays
  • Other paid time that never lands on a job

Here’s the trap. ServiceTitan’s job costing documentation says that if you include labor pay and performance pay in job costing, you should subtract payroll costs from the technician’s burden rate. Otherwise you count the same wages twice and your jobs look worse than they are. Too low and you’re guessing. Too high and you’re scaring yourself out of good work.

Burden rate problem What the job report shows What really happened
No burden loaded Fat margins on every job Taxes, comp, PTO and benefits never reached a job
One blended rate for everyone Margins off by tech and by job type Your $22 helper and $45 lead are costed the same
Wages included twice Margins too thin Labor pay counted in pay and again in burden
Rate set two years ago Slowly drifting margins Raises, new hires and benefit changes never got loaded

Do I need one burden rate or more than one?

Short answer: More than one if your crews are really different. Prevailing wage work is the clearest case.

If you do prevailing wage or certified payroll work, one blended rate will burn you. Use one rate for regular work and another for prevailing wage.

What works in practice:

  • A rate per person for your field staff, built from their actual pay and benefits.
  • An average rate for new hires until you have real numbers for them.
  • A quarterly review. Crew mix changes, raises happen, benefits renew. Put it on the calendar.

If you’ve been running without a burden rate, don’t try to restate every old job by hand. Load the rates going forward, then decide with your accountant whether open jobs need a correcting entry.

Why didn’t my timesheet edit fix the job?

Short answer: ServiceTitan doesn’t re-sync payroll data into job costing when you edit a past timesheet. You have to push the update.

ServiceTitan’s help center covers this for accounts on the standard job costing model. Job costing uses the payroll data from the period the job was completed. Edit an old timesheet and the job still shows the old cost until you go to Payroll Approval, pick the date range, find the tech, and click Update now.

Two more timing rules that cause headaches:

  • The job costing view locks once the invoice is posted and exported. Payroll adjustments made after that won’t show on that job.
  • Commissions only show in payroll reports once the invoice is posted or exported. If a tech’s pay looks short, check the invoice status before you call the payroll provider.

The fix is a habit, not a tool. Make every time edit in ServiceTitan before payroll is approved. Never fix hours only in the payroll system.

What should I check every month?

Short answer: Compare total field labor in ServiceTitan to field labor in QuickBooks Online, by business unit, and explain the gap.

You don’t need to tie every job to the penny, just to know the gap is small and why it exists.

  1. Lock time first. Clear missing clock-outs and disputes, then approve payroll in ServiceTitan.
  2. Check the payroll journal. The payroll register, employer tax report, benefits deductions and workers’ comp from your provider should match the wages, taxes and benefits in QuickBooks Online for the month.
  3. Code labor to the right place. Field wages go to cost of goods sold by department or class, not to one big wages account.
  4. Compare totals. ServiceTitan job labor plus burden for the month against QuickBooks Online direct labor plus taxes and benefits.
  5. Name the gap. Drive time, shop time, training, callbacks and PTO are normal reasons. “We don’t know” is not.
  6. Check open POs and bills. Material cost that looks light usually means invoices are missing. Tie vendor bills to jobs in ServiceTitan so the customer reference can carry into QuickBooks Online.
  7. Update burden rates if the gap keeps pointing the same direction.

Can I get a weekly gross margin number?

Short answer: Yes, if you cost labor at your burden rates during the week and true it up to real payroll at month-end.

Lots of owners want gross margin by Tuesday, but payroll often isn’t final yet. Don’t wait for it. Use ServiceTitan’s burdened labor for the weekly number, then true up to actual payroll when you close the month. A fast number built on messy books is just a fast wrong number.

Where does Rektio fit?

Short answer: We keep the QuickBooks Online side right every month and help you set rates you can trust.

We are a monthly bookkeeping and controller team for home-service companies on ServiceTitan. Each month a team of two or three people books payroll by department, reviews payroll against timesheets, reconciles banks and cards, and closes the month in QuickBooks Online. A U.S.-based account manager reviews the work before you see it. We help you build a burden rate sheet and tell you when it’s drifting.

We don’t sell ServiceTitan setup or training, and we’re not a ServiceTitan partner. Pricing starts at $1,500 a month, scoped to your business, month-to-month with 30 days’ notice. If your books are behind, we almost always build catch-up into the onboarding fee or handle it as a special onboarding project.

More reading: why ServiceTitan deposits don’t match the bank, moving from QuickBooks Desktop to Online with ServiceTitan, and our ServiceTitan bookkeeping page. Call or text (463) 215-0968, or book a call.

FAQ

Does ServiceTitan send payroll to QuickBooks Online?

No. ServiceTitan’s help docs say payroll doesn’t export directly to QuickBooks. You send approved hours to your payroll provider, and the provider’s payroll journal is what lands in QuickBooks Online. A direct connection, like Inova (UKG Ready), can cut the file export, but it does not replace a correct burden rate.

Why is ServiceTitan job costing different from my QuickBooks P&L?

ServiceTitan costs labor with hours times a burden rate someone entered. Your payroll provider shows what you actually paid, and that usually posts to QuickBooks Online. Missing or stale burden rates, time edited only in payroll, and non-job time like drive and shop time are the usual reasons the two disagree.

What should be included in a technician burden rate?

Usually employer payroll taxes, workers’ comp, benefits, paid time off and holidays. If labor pay and performance pay are already included in job costing, subtract payroll costs from the burden rate so wages aren’t counted twice.

Why didn’t my timesheet edit change the job cost?

Editing a past timesheet doesn’t re-sync payroll data into job costing on its own. In ServiceTitan, go to Payroll Approval, select the date range, find the technician and click Update now. If the invoice was already posted and exported, the job costing view is locked.

How often should burden rates be updated?

At least once a quarter, and any time pay, benefits or crew mix change in a big way. Use separate rates for prevailing wage and regular work.

Is Rektio a ServiceTitan partner?

No. Rektio Accounting is an independent bookkeeping and controller team. We work in QuickBooks Online for home-service companies that use ServiceTitan. We don’t sell ServiceTitan setup or training.